Policing Black Female Sexuality

Nicki Minaj for Paper Magazine

Nicki Minaj for Paper Magazine

 

 

 

Black women have consistently been targeted primarily for being outspoken about their sex lives, or lack thereof.

When Yvonne Orji publicly addressed her virginity and her decision behind it, people on social media criticized her for having her sex life be controlled by a religion.

When #ForTheD challenge became popular on social media and prominent black actresses like Issa Rae, Sanaa Lathan, and Regina Hall participated, there was some side-eying from primarily black Christian women who thought that those women were doing too much and shouldn’t be involved in such licentious behavior. I could imagine all the old church ladies rolling their eyes in chorus.

When Gabrielle Union, on a press tour for her book, discussed that she started masturbating at a young age, people on social media were surprised to hear that a prominent “classy black woman” like Gabrielle Union would be so open about her sex life, as if being classy and having an enjoyable sex life were mutually exclusive.

When Cardi B got engaged to Offset from the popular rap trio Migos, some women were upset that a former stripper and provocative reality star got the ring before they did.

Because of those criticisms, the four instances can be rewritten as the following:

Yvonne Orji has no sex. Virgin. Not because she wants to but because she’s not desirable.

Gabrielle Union had sexual pleasures too early. Too experienced. She shouldn’t share that in her book.

Issa Rae has lots of sex. Awkward, yes. Black, yes. But sexy and openly desiring the dick? Nah.

Cardi B has too much sex, and she shouldn’t be rewarded for it. Stripper. Risque. Ho. Not the right woman to represent rap.

Fast forward about three weeks later, and Nicki Minaj found herself in similar discussion.

Nicki Minaj. Queen of rap, but not queen of her body. Forced sex appeal. Provocative. Too much sex. Too old to be doing the same thing. Where’s the philanthropic Nicki?

Those instances only tell me, a 19-year old sexually active black female, two things. First, people still have this archaic issue stemmed in deeply-rooted classicism  about black women talking about their sex lives, which basically boils down to us being damned if we do and damned if we don’t. Second, a woman’s worth seems to be  tied to what goes inside her body, and if that woman just so happens to be black, then she might as well file a virtual cease-and-desist-order against herself from talking about her sexual pleasures.

Thus, the backlash that appeared in response to Nicki Minaj’s “Paper Magazine” cover reiterated those notions and introduced another one⸺ that black women haven’t fully embraced their sexual liberation to the extent that they claim to be.

The main critique of Minaj’s unsurprisingly eye-catching cover came from black women. It ranged from the “I don’t know where I stand on this” to the “I thought Nicki was over this part of her life; Cardi B must have sher shook”. Those remarks were obviously filled with respectability politics, which has been the main concept that oppresses the black female body. However, I found it interesting that it came from black feminists, black women who claim on social media every day to be actively fighting for against the oppression of black women. Thus, it seems as if they either forgot about that fight or more importantly, and likely the more appropriate reasoning for this matter, respectability politics aligned with principles embedded in Christianity in terms of women owning their bodies have become deeply ingrained into the psyche of black women that, honestly, we still haven’t come to terms with the agency of our own bodies. Furthermore, the previous notion is totally understandable, given how people constantly want to control our bodies.

I will be the first to say that women have the right to do whatever they want with their bodies.Because of the historic oppression of black women related to their bodies, black female sexual agency is a revolutionary act.

The concept is particularly revolutionary because people within and outside of the black community have done everything in their power to suppress it. It’s no secret that black women have always been perceived as more mature sexual beings before appropriately being considered as such. According to a recent study by Georgetown Law Center on Poverty and Equity titled “Girlhood Interrupted: The Erasure of Black Girls’ Childhood”, black girls, between the ages of 5-14, are viewed as less innocent than their white counterparts. Among the abhorrent conclusions of that study, participants in that survey believed that black girls knew more about sex than their white counterparts. It isn’t no surprise that black women are deemed more sexually mature; it’s a perception that dates back to slavery.

Respectability politics aligned with principles embedded in Christianity in terms of women owning their bodies have become deeply ingrained into the psyche of black women that, honestly, we still haven’t come to terms with the agency of our own bodies

During slavery, rape against a black woman was not considered illegal. In fact, black women’s sexuality was not their own as they were constant targets for sex from their white masters. Consider the story of Harriet Jacobs. She started receiving sexual advances from her white master at the age of 15, and he wouldn’t stop doing it simply because he admired that power he had over her, which is main reason why he had no intention to sell her. However, she did manage to escape in order to save her children. Stories similar to that warrant the case for the perception of black women as hypersexual.

Thus during the early twentieth century, black women (primarily Christian) attempted to dismiss those hypersexual perceptions by instituting long skirts, forcing messages of virginity and abstinence, and promoting other “modest” behaviors under the guise of respectability politics. Evelyn Brooks Higginbotham was the first to coin the term in her “Righteous Discontent: The Women’s Movement in the Black Baptist Church: 1880-1920” in which she discussed how black churches became an integral aspect of racial uplift and self-help for black people and also how black women spearheaded that occurrence by instituting schools and social welfare services.

While I understand the attempt to show people (white people) that black people aren’t the perceived stereotypes and can be participants of a more “respectable” society, thus it became a form of resistance for those women, I better understand that the current state of respectability politics attempts to blame the victim (in this case, black women) instead of the people who created the necessity for respectability politics (in this case, America). Therefore in preaching virginity and modest clothing to black girls in part to disassociate them with the pleasures of sex altogether, people are indirectly contributing to this constant policing of the black female body.

So, no, Nicki Minaj isn’t forcing her sex appeal. This isn’t a phase of hers. She doesn’t need to change to a more respectable image because now she’s more established. She is simply being Nicki Minaj and taking ownership of her body in a care-free, unapologetic way. And if you criticize her for that, then you’re a part of the problem.

On Colorism, Respectability Politics, and Cardi B

Getty Images/Alberto Rodriguez

Getty Images/Alberto Rodriguez

Last week, Cardi B made history as the first female rapper since Lauryn Hill to reach the top of the Billboard Hot 100 chart without any guest appearances. Her hit single, “Bodak Yellow”, dethroned Taylor’s Swift “Look What You Made Me Do”. Although Cardi B’s historic success was met with praise across social media and beyond, it didn’t take long for people to question the value of it.

Within a day of Cardi B taking the number one spot, there were a plethora of facebook posts on my timeline expressing how discouraged they were about Cardi B being the image of success for young black girls. Most of the posts were from Christian women who couldn’t fathom a stripper-turned-reality star-turned-rapper being a leader for women. One post in particular even did the cringe-worthy hazard of comparing Cardi B to Michelle Obama, obviously emphasizing that she wanted her daughter to be more like the former first lady and not the unapologetic rapper who has no filter.

I can’t say that seeing post like the one mentioned above surprised me. As progressive as this generation of millennials are, there’s still an odorous tinge of traditionalism that highlights how respectability politics prevails in black culture.  My first reaction was basically filled with concern because I knew those posts were not the right message to be sending young black girls, and I also knew that it was wrong to diminish one’s success because of their past.

I will be the first to say that comparing Cardi B to Michelle Obama, Oprah, or any other black women whose rise to success seemingly makes them more conducive to being a “leader for young black girls” has respectability politics written all over it (in all caps, followed by an exclamation point). Just because someone’s rise to success doesn’t align with other’s perception of what success should look like, doesn’t mean that it should be demeaned and contained. Furthermore, that notion is attendant to the archaic idea of black elitism in which the divide between middle class, church-going, respectably mannered black women and the perceivably unkempt, loud-mouthed,and misunderstood black girls from the hood becomes more apparent.

This is a notion that was also held by Azealia Banks who mentioned, among other things, that stripper culture should not be the face of hip-hop and Cardi B representing that is an issue. Besides the fact that Banks isn’t in any position to declare what the face of female hip-hop should be, she subconsciously contributed to the faulty reasoning that a black woman’s profession defines her worth and assuming that all women who are strippers chose to be in that position . Cardi B’s rise is an obvious suggestion of the opposite. In fact, like some black women who are strippers, Cardi B became a one because it was an escape from poverty and the domestic violence incited by an ex-boyfriend. Although it’s a desired profession for some, it’s a means of escape for others. That’s obviously illustrated in “Bodak Yellow” with Cardi B rapping “I don’t dance now. I make money moves”.  Furthermore, I will also be the first to argue that Cardi B’s rise to success should be an example for all black girls that they can fulfill their dreams when the odds are heavily stacked against them

The second aspect of the criticism of Cardi B involved Azealia Banks again. In typical Azealia Banks fashion, the highly controversial rapper took to social media to express that colorism helped Cardi B ascend to the top, even going at length to label her “a poor man’s Nicki” (insert straight-face emoji here).

 

azealia-cardi-tweets-1.png

Immediately following her twitter thread, there were black feminists who defended her under the guise of colorism and Banks’ mental illness. Basically, social media defenses of Banks  varied between the “Banks is a dark-skinned women, so we have to acknowledge her disadvantage in society, and choosing Cardi B over her just perpetuates the colorism narrative” facebook post and the “We have to address mental health and how it take its toll on black women” twitter thread.

 

Don't get me wrong. I am well aware that hip-hop culture regularly demeans black women and has a long history of contributing to misogynoir. I will also admit that hip-hop does have a behind-the-scenes colorism issue. I only use that term because I do believe that hip-hop is probably the only platform in which the dark-skinned women are more accepted. Lauryn Hill, Missy Elliott, Rah Digga, and more are examples of hip-hop being a welcoming environment for dark-skinned black women. Additionally, to counter Banks’ claim of black men not hyping them up, it was Russell Simmons and Jay-Z who believed in a 17-year-old rapper from Brooklyn, New York, by the name of Foxy Brown and immediately signed her to Def Jam Records. It was Timbaland’s production skills that helped elevate Missy Elliott to hip-hop regality. I can go on and on and list examples of how black men have helped dark-skinned black women and even put them on the map.

However, I am not oblivious to colorism being a hidden issue. Whether we like it or not, there’s truth to Lil Kim’s decision to bleach her skin and Azealia  Banks’  decision to do the same. Additionally, I believe that Banks did accomplish shedding light on the colorism dialogue in hip-hop because although the issue isn’t prevalent in hip-hop doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist in that realm.

Nevertheless, those truths  don’t reduce my thoughts on labeling Azealia Banks an asshole. And I’m not going to use colorism and her mental health as excuses for her being that way. I don’t believe there is more depth to her comments on Cardi B than simply being a bitter, self-destructive female rapper who's jealous because Cardi B's social media feuds aren’t more famous than her actual music.

I find it distressing that black woman’s historic accomplishments are being unpacked and analyzed as a means to belittle her success. Cardi B is a perfect illustration of the potential that black girls have in an environment that’s increasingly stifling to their success and that, in itself, doesn’t require any further analysis.



 

On Miley Cyrus, Hip-Hop, and the Objectification of Black Women

This piece is not to demonize girls like Miley Cyrus. I respect her art, but I cannot respect what she has represented.

***This article was inspired by a thought-provoking conversation between my boyfriend and I.

Wiz Khalifa, Miley Cyrus, and Juicy J; Rolling Out magazine

Wiz Khalifa, Miley Cyrus, and Juicy J; Rolling Out magazine

 

Last week, in a recent interview with Billboard magazine, Miley Cyrus explained how she would return to her musical roots. But she also indirectly admitted to appropriating hip-hop while promoting her “new” sound. When asked if Melanie Safka influenced her new music, Cyrus responded with the following:

“She did, and I grew up with her. But I also love that new Kendrick [Lamar] song [‘Humble’]: ‘Show me somethin’ natural like ass with some stretch marks.’ I love that because it’s not ‘Come sit on my dick, suck on my cock.’ I can’t listen to that anymore. That’s what pushed me out of the hip-hop scene a little. It was too much ‘Lamborghini, got my Rolex, got a girl on my cock’ -- I am so not that.”

Her words circled my mind around three conclusions. The first one was obviously how Miley Cyrus profited off hip-hop in order to make a hit record. Whether she wants to admit it or not, Cyrus used hip-hop only when it was convenient for her. Her words in the interview cemented the idea that her grandiose display of twerking, trying-to-hard-to-be-blackness and association with prominent hip-hop artists was just a phase of typical, non-intersectional white feminism. I can go on and on about how Cyrus reflects the trend of whiteness admiring black culture by appropriating it and explain the historical significance, but I will not shower her with that much attention. She simply isn’t worth it. There are many blogs, facebook posts, and twitter threads that have been written within the past 48 hours that accurately explain how Miley Cyrus is a representation of peak white womanhood. But this blog is not one of them. Instead I will focus more on my next two points---hip-hop and the objectification of black women.

The next conclusion that came to mind was how much black men validated Cyrus’ phase. Popular rappers and producers like Future, Juicy J, Mike WiLL Made It, and others clearly didn’t think that Cyrus’ appropriation was enough for them to stop working for her, which is very problematic. Their gracious welcome to the singer illustrates how black men are complicit in this cultural appropriation in terms of white women. Black men’s instant acceptance of white girls who wear hip-hop and black culture as a costume only perpetuate the occurrence. The sad thing is that those white women are equally aware of this. They know that if they get those butt injections, wear their hair in a style that is typically seen on black women, and display the littlest glimpse of them being “down for the culture”, they will automatically be welcomed with open arms by black men who will perceive them as alternatives to black women.

The saddest and most unfortunate aspect of this situation is that black women will call out the white woman before calling out the black men who accept them. I have been a victim of this. I would automatically be disgusted with the white woman who appropriated our culture. Instead of being mad about the existence of Kylie Jenner’s popularity based off of black culture and black women’s style, I should have been just as upset with Tyga and other black men who acknowledged her and chose her over black women. White girls like Kylie Jenner and Miley Cyrus would not have gained as much hype within the black community if black men would have shown even a little bit of adamance in not normalizing them. But that just reflects black women’s unrequited loyalty to black men.

The fact that black hip-hop artists are offenders of this speaks volumes. It only adds to the narrative hip-hop failing black women and the larger trend of black men not protecting black women, which brings me to my next point. Regardless of how hypocritical Miley Cyrus’ statement was, which it was very hypocritical, she did have one point------hip-hop is very misogynistic. Furthermore, hip-hop has especially been that way in terms of black women. For instance, I think the Notorious B.I.G. is among the top three rappers of all-time. But I cannot gloss over his highly misogynistic lyrics. In “Me and My Bitch” from the iconic Ready to Die album, Biggie raps a love song to the one he loves by emphasizing the point that she will always be there to protect him: “Love me when I’m broke or when I’m filthy fuckin’ rich and I admit, when the time is right, the wine is right, I’ll treat you right, talk slick, I beat you right”. Biggie loves the girl because of her devotion to him regardless of anything that he does, even beating her, basically treating her as his bitch ( thus, the song title). Another example of Biggie’s misogynistic lyrics are found in the songs “Fucking You Tonight”, which features R. Kelly on the chorus. Now, R.Kelly’s popularity in R&B is problematic in itself, and it will be discussed in another post for another day. But, the song basically talks about the guy spending his money and on the finer things in life so much that she has owes him sex.

Lyrics such as those have been used throughout hip-hop for years, and the perception of black women as sexual objects has unfortunately played a huge role in hip-hop culture to the point where it is ubiquitous in almost every song. I only used Biggie as an example because he is hip-hop royalty, and his lyrical and stylistic prominence should not erase his misogyny.

In order for hip-hop to escape this perilous theme, there needs to be a black woman’s perspective. “But there’s Nicki Minaj”, you say. Yes, Nicki is significant in her own right and has done a lot for women in hip-hop in terms of building their own empire, but she certainly is not woke enough to handle the issue. I’m not saying that she needs to be; everyone isn’t called to be woke. And as political as Kendrick Lamar is, he can’t even be the one to offer the female narrative, which was shown by the controversy in the same lyrics that Miley Cyrus referenced. But in order to tackle hip-hop’s degradation of black women, we need a woke female hip-hop artist. This is why LAURYN HILL WAS SO ICONIC! This is also why I’m mad at her for not making any more music. We need another Lauryn Hill to offer the female perspective in hip-hop because this certainly needs to stop. With The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill, Lauryn Hill is illustrated a black woman’s identity through the lens of love.

We don’t get enough of that in hip-hop. Instead, a black woman’s identity has been demoted to an object that is subservient to black men. It all illustrates the general idea of black men simply not protecting/defending black women enough.